The Right Tool for the Right Job: BOLI for Banks, COLI for Corporations

![[HERO] Bank and corporate executives collaborating on BOLI and COLI planning for employee benefits and executive retention.](https://images.pexels.com/photos/3183150/pexels-photo-3183150.jpeg)

In business, clarity beats complexity. The right tool in the right hands can solve the right problem. The wrong tool, even if it looks similar on paper, creates confusion fast.

If you are a bank leader, you do not need to wonder whether COLI belongs on your balance sheet. It does not. If you are running a corporation, LLC, or partnership, you do not need to sort through BOLI literature. It is not your vehicle.

At Schiff Executive Benefits, we spend our days answering these "What If's." What if top talent leaves? What if retirement costs are rising faster than expected? What if a buy-sell obligation shows up before you are financially ready? We do not start with a product. We reverse engineer solutions based on your goals, your entity type, and your regulatory environment.

That is why this conversation is not about competition between BOLI and COLI. It is about fit. Both use employer-owned life insurance mechanics. Both can support long-term executive benefit planning. But they belong in different worlds.

The Right Tool for the Right Job

The easiest way to frame this is simple.

If you are a bank, credit union, or thrift, you are in the BOLI world.
Bank-Owned Life Insurance is a specialized asset class for financial institutions. It is used to help informally fund employee benefits and generate tax-advantaged income on the institution's balance sheet. It is also heavily regulated by the OCC, FDIC, and state banking departments, which means design, due diligence, and administration matter. You can learn more about our specific BOLI consulting services here.

If you are a corporation, LLC, or partnership, you are in the COLI world.
Corporate-Owned Life Insurance is the broader planning tool for non-bank businesses. It is often used to support executive retention strategies, key-person coverage, buy-sell planning, and nonqualified deferred compensation (NQDC) plans. For companies evaluating deferred compensation design, it also pairs naturally with broader executive benefit planning.

The mechanics may be similar. The use cases may overlap at a high level. But the entity determines the vehicle.

Where COLI Fits in the Corporate World

For corporations, LLCs, and partnerships, COLI is often part of a much broader retention and succession strategy. Many business owners are asset rich and cash poor. Their value is tied up in the business. That works well until a buyout, retirement, death, or executive transition forces a liquidity event.

If you have a buy-sell agreement in place, how will it be funded? If a key executive retires, how will you replace that talent cost-efficiently? If your best people are being recruited, what are you doing today to make staying more valuable than leaving?

This is where COLI can shine. A properly structured plan can help fund obligations tied to executive retention, deferred compensation, key-person risk, and ownership transition. It can create what we call an Ownership Feel to Non-Owners while helping the business maintain control, liquidity, and long-term alignment.

For banks, those same broad concerns may exist. But the funding vehicle is BOLI, not COLI. That distinction matters.

The "In the Room" Expertise: IRC 101(j) and 409A

Rules matter. Entity type matters. Documentation matters. This is where a lot of well-meaning advisors get lost.

When we talk about BOLI and COLI, we are not reading from a brochure. Matt Schiff brings a deep technical legacy to this work. Back in 2003 and 2005, he was in the room where it happened. As a ranking member of the AALU's NQDC Committee, he worked alongside Michael Goldstein to help draft the very laws that govern these plans today: IRC 409A and IRC 101(j).

That matters because these rules do not disappear just because you picked the right entity-specific vehicle. IRC 101(j) and 409A apply to both BOLI and COLI where relevant. Whether you are a bank implementing BOLI or a corporation structuring COLI around deferred compensation, technical compliance is still the backbone of a successful outcome.

If you want to hear more about that era and the technical nuances of these regulations, I highly recommend listening to my podcast interview with Dan Hogans, who was formerly with the IRS Treasury and was a key architect of these rules.

The 101(j) Trap

One area where many generalist advisors trip up is IRC 101(j). This regulation governs employer-owned life insurance. To keep the death benefits of a BOLI or COLI policy income-tax-free, you must comply with strict notice and consent requirements before the policy is issued.

If you fail to get the employee's written consent or fail to file the annual IRS Form 8925, the death proceeds that should help the business can suddenly become taxable income. We see this all too often in legacy plans that have never been audited. At Schiff Executive Benefits, we make sure your program is designed to comply from day one, Restoring Alignment and Retention to your organization.

The Perfect Plan^® Starts with the Right Vehicle

In today’s competitive landscape, good enough benefits do not cut it. Your best people are being recruited every single day. To keep them, you need a strategy that fits your organization and speaks directly to the outcomes your leadership team cares about.

This is why we developed The Perfect Plan^®. It is not just a product. It is a philosophy. The process starts by identifying the right vehicle for the right entity, then designing the plan around the outcome.

That means:

• Banks may use BOLI to help fund employee benefits and create tax-advantaged balance sheet support.
• Corporations, LLCs, and partnerships may use COLI to support Deferred Compensation (NQDC), executive retention, key-person coverage, and buy-sell planning.
• Both require thoughtful design, regulatory awareness, and coordination with your broader advisory team.

Imagine telling your top executive: If you stay with us for the next ten years, we have a plan that provides 100% income when you need it most in retirement, and 100% protection for your family if something happens to you tomorrow.

That is the power of a properly structured plan. It aligns the executive’s personal financial goals with the company’s long-term health.

Why the "Reverse Engineering" Approach?

Most brokers start with a product. We do not work that way.

We work as a broker with any carrier, which allows us to stay agnostic. We start with your "What If's."

• Are you a bank trying to offset benefit costs efficiently?
• Are you a corporation preparing for a business buyout?
• Are you concerned about the cost of replacing a senior executive?
• Are you looking for 100% cost recovery for the employer?
• Are you trying to keep your top talent from leaving?

Once we have the goal, we reverse engineer the solution. We work alongside your existing team of advisors: your Accountant, Attorney, and TPA: to ensure that the BOLI or COLI structure fits your legal, tax, and cultural framework.

Your Next Steps

Building a business is hard. Protecting it should not be. The first step is simple: identify your world.

If you are a bank, credit union, or thrift, your conversation starts with BOLI and the banking guidance that surrounds it. If you are a corporation, LLC, or partnership, your conversation starts with COLI and how it supports retention, buy-sell planning, and deferred compensation.

If you are ready to see how the right vehicle fits into your situation, I invite you to take a low-pressure first step. Use our Business Valuation tool to get a clearer picture of what you have built.

From there, we can sit down, grab a coffee, and talk through the practical next move. If you want to go deeper first, explore our Deferred Compensation and NQDC planning page, our COLI strategy overview, or our BOLI consulting page for banks.

To stay updated on the latest strategies for business owners and executives, visit our latest posts here or join the conversation over at The Perfect Plan^® on YouTube.