Corporate Owned Life Insurance (COLI): Strategic Financial Security

The Short Answer

Corporate Owned Life Insurance (COLI) is life insurance a company buys on the lives of selected employees, where the company owns the policy, pays the premium, and is named beneficiary. Businesses use COLI as a tax-advantaged balance sheet asset to informally finance executive benefit obligations — deferred compensation, supplemental retirement promises, split dollar arrangements — with the goal of recovering the cost of those benefits over time. Cash value inside the policy generally grows tax-deferred, and death proceeds are generally received income-tax-free, provided the company satisfies the notice and consent requirements of IRC 101(j) before the policy is issued.

COLI is also called company owned life insurance or employer-owned life insurance. When the buyer is a bank, the same structure is called BOLI. When the buyer is an insurance carrier, it is called iCOLI. The mechanics are largely the same; the regulator and the accounting context differ.

What Is Corporate Owned Life Insurance?

At its core, COLI is employer-owned life insurance placed on eligible employees for a legitimate business purpose. The structure has four moving parts:

• The company owns the policy. It holds every incident of ownership — the right to borrow, surrender, change the beneficiary, and direct any investment allocation.
• The company pays the premium. Premiums are not deductible. This is a capital allocation decision, not an expense strategy.
• The company is the beneficiary. Proceeds are payable to the business, though many designs share a portion with the insured’s family as an added benefit.
• The insured employee gives written notice and consent before issue. This is not a formality. Miss it and the tax treatment of the death benefit changes permanently.

The planning value is not in the insurance itself. It is in what the asset does inside the business. A properly designed COLI case takes capital that would otherwise sit in taxable short-term instruments and repositions it into a vehicle whose growth is tax-deferred, whose eventual proceeds are generally tax-free, and whose timing can be matched to a liability the company has already promised to pay.

How COLI Life Insurance Works as a Balance Sheet Asset

COLI should be evaluated as a long-term corporate asset, not as a current-year tax play. The policy’s cash surrender value is carried as an asset on the company’s books. Growth inside the contract is generally not currently taxable. For a business comparing alternatives, that can create a materially more efficient holding environment than fully taxable fixed income or short-term corporate cash.

The analysis that matters is a comparison, not an absolute. The question is never “is COLI a good asset?” It is “compared to the taxable alternative this company would otherwise hold for the same duration, what is the after-tax outcome?” That comparison depends on the company’s marginal tax rate, its holding period, its liquidity needs, and its tolerance for an asset that is not marked to market daily.

What COLI Is Typically Used to Finance

• Nonqualified deferred compensation liabilities, including employee-deferral plans and employer-funded arrangements
• Supplemental Executive Retirement Plan (SERP) obligations
• Split dollar program financing
• Phantom stock and other synthetic equity payouts
• Key person risk — replacing the economic loss when a critical executive dies
• Buy-sell and business succession funding
• General long-term benefit obligations that sit on the balance sheet without a matched asset

The common thread is duration. Every one of these is a promise the company has made that comes due years from now. COLI is a way to hold an asset whose characteristics resemble the liability it is meant to support.

COLI vs. BOLI vs. iCOLI: Which Applies to You

The three acronyms describe the same fundamental structure under three different owners, and they are frequently confused.

• COLI — Corporate Owned Life Insurance. Bought by an operating company, professional firm, or partnership. Governed by the general tax rules discussed on this page.
• BOLI — Bank Owned Life Insurance. Same structure, bank buyer, plus a layer of banking regulation. Federal regulators expect banks to conduct a pre-purchase analysis and to observe concentration guidance relative to capital.
• iCOLI — Institutional Corporate Owned Life Insurance. Bought by insurance carriers to optimize capital and surplus. Different accounting regime, different risk framework.

If you are trying to decide which structure fits your institution, our companion piece on choosing between BOLI and COLI covers the decision in detail.

IRC 101(j): The Rule That Makes or Breaks a COLI Case

This is the single most important technical rule in employer-owned life insurance, and it is where most damaged cases go wrong.

Before the Pension Protection Act of 2006, employer-owned death benefits were generally income-tax-free with few conditions. The Act added IRC 101(j), which reversed the default. For an employer-owned life insurance contract, death proceeds are now taxable income to the employer above the premiums paid unless the arrangement satisfies both a notice-and-consent requirement and one of several exceptions.

The Notice and Consent Requirement

Before the policy is issued, the employee must:

1. Be notified in writing that the employer intends to insure their life, and be told the maximum face amount for which they could be insured at the time the contract is issued;
2. Give written consent to being insured, and to the coverage continuing after the insured terminates employment; and
3. Be informed in writing that the employer will be a beneficiary of any proceeds payable on the employee’s death.

The timing word is before. Consent obtained after issue does not cure the defect, and there is no general retroactive fix. A signature missing from a file years ago can convert a tax-free death benefit into ordinary income at the worst possible moment.

The Exceptions

Assuming notice and consent were properly completed, proceeds remain generally income-tax-free if the insured falls into a qualifying category — broadly, an insured who was an employee within twelve months of death, or who at the time the contract was issued was a director, a highly compensated employee, or a highly compensated individual as those terms are defined in the Code. There is also an exception for proceeds paid to the insured’s heirs or used to purchase an equity interest from them.

This is why COLI is not a rank-and-file product. The eligible insured class is narrow by design, and confirming eligibility at issue is part of the underwriting discipline, not an afterthought.

Annual Reporting: IRS Form 8925

An employer holding employer-owned life insurance contracts generally files Form 8925 with its annual tax return, reporting the number of employees insured, the total amount of insurance in force, and confirming that valid consent is on file for each insured. Companies that acquire businesses often inherit policies without inheriting the consent documentation. If you have grown through acquisition and hold policies you did not originate, that file review should happen now rather than at a claim.

Accounting Treatment

Under U.S. GAAP, an investment in a life insurance contract is generally reported at the amount that could be realized under the contract as of the balance sheet date — in practice, cash surrender value, net of any applicable surrender charges the company would actually incur. Changes in that realizable amount flow through income. Death proceeds in excess of carrying value are recognized when the claim is realizable.

Two practical consequences follow. First, the reported asset in early policy years is the cash surrender value, not the premium paid, and in some designs those differ meaningfully at the outset. Second, your auditor will want to see the carrier’s annual statement supporting the carrying value. Neither is a problem in a well-designed case, but both should be discussed with your CPA before the first premium is paid, not after the first audit.

Cost Recovery: The Mechanic That Justifies the Structure

Cost recovery is the reason most companies use COLI rather than simply accruing the liability and paying benefits from operating cash.

The sequence works like this:

1. The company makes a benefit promise — a deferred compensation account, a SERP, a phantom stock award — that comes due in the future.
2. Rather than leaving that liability unmatched, the company allocates capital to a COLI policy on the insured executive.
3. Cash value accumulates on a tax-deferred basis over the working career.
4. When benefits become payable, the company can access policy values, subject to policy terms, to help fund them. Benefit payments to the executive are generally deductible to the company when paid and taxable to the executive when received.
5. At the insured’s death, the carrier pays proceeds to the company. Subject to compliance with 101(j) and the transfer-for-value rules, those proceeds are generally income-tax-free and can substantially restore the capital the company committed.

That final step is what advisors mean by “cost recovery.” It does not make the benefit free, and any projection of full recovery depends on assumptions — policy performance, mortality timing, tax rates, and the discipline of leaving the structure intact — that should be stress-tested rather than accepted. A design that only works at an illustrated rate is not a design. Ask to see it at guaranteed assumptions before you commit capital.

Where COLI Cases Go Wrong

In thirty years of reviewing existing programs, the same failures recur:

• Missing or late 101(j) consent. The most common and the most expensive. Almost always discovered at claim.
• Transfer-for-value exposure. Moving a policy between entities in a reorganization, or to a partner or shareholder, can taint the tax-free death benefit under IRC 101(a)(2) unless it lands in a recognized safe harbor.
• Orphaned policies. The producer retired, nobody has reviewed performance in a decade, and the carrying assumptions no longer hold.
• Asset and liability that don’t match. The benefit promise was designed by one advisor and the funding by another, and the two were never reconciled.
• Design that ignores 409A. The insurance can be perfect and the underlying deferred compensation plan can still fail. See our guide to 409A compliance.

If you already hold COLI or BOLI and have not had it independently reviewed, our piece on the seven most common portfolio mistakes is a reasonable place to start.

Designing COLI Around the Liability

A COLI case should be engineered around the obligation it is intended to support — never the reverse. That means identifying the liability, measuring when it comes due, selecting the appropriate insureds, and evaluating how policy performance interacts with the broader benefit design.

At Schiff Executive Benefits we start with the technical objective and reverse engineer the structure around the company’s financial intent, its liability profile, and its compliance requirements. Whether the goal is to support deferred compensation, coordinate with a split dollar program, or finance a phantom stock payout, the financing has to match the promise. That methodology is the core of The Perfect Plan®.

The Technical Advantage

Compliance in this field is not a checkbox. It is the difference between a tax-free asset and a serious tax problem. In 2003 and 2005, our President, Matt Schiff, served as a ranking member of the AALU’s NQDC Committee alongside Michael Goldstein, working on the industry response to the regulations that became IRC 409A and IRC 101(j). When we discuss COLI compliance, we are drawing on direct involvement in how these rules took shape.

You can hear more on the technical history in Matt’s interview with Dan Hogans, formerly of the Treasury Department, on The Perfect Plan® Podcast.

Frequently Asked Questions About COLI

What is the difference between COLI and company owned life insurance?

Nothing. They are two names for the same structure. “Corporate owned life insurance” and “company owned life insurance” are used interchangeably, and the Code refers to it as employer-owned life insurance. Some advisors reserve “company owned” for non-corporate entities such as partnerships and LLCs, but the tax rules under IRC 101(j) apply to all of them.

Are COLI premiums tax deductible?

No. Premiums paid on a policy where the company is a direct or indirect beneficiary are not deductible under IRC 264. The tax advantage of COLI is on the accumulation and death benefit side, not the premium side. Any presentation that suggests otherwise should be a red flag.

Is the COLI death benefit tax-free?

Generally yes, but only if the arrangement satisfies IRC 101(j) — proper written notice and consent before issue, plus a qualifying insured — and does not run afoul of the transfer-for-value rules. If those conditions are not met, proceeds above the premiums paid are taxable as ordinary income to the company.

Can a company buy COLI on any employee?

Practically, no. The 101(j) exceptions effectively limit favorable treatment to directors, highly compensated employees and individuals as defined in the Code, and recent employees. Broad-based coverage of rank-and-file employees — the practice that drew scrutiny in the 1990s and prompted the 2006 legislation — is not how modern COLI is designed.

Does the employee need to consent to COLI?

Yes, in writing, before the policy is issued. The employee must be told the maximum face amount, must consent to coverage continuing after employment ends, and must be informed that the employer will be a beneficiary. Consent cannot be obtained retroactively.

What happens to a COLI policy when the insured leaves the company?

The company continues to own the policy and may keep it in force, which is precisely why the consent language must disclose that possibility up front. Whether keeping it makes sense is an economic question that depends on the policy’s performance and the liability it was purchased to support.

How is COLI different from key person insurance?

Key person insurance is one use case for COLI. It covers the economic loss to the business when a critical individual dies. Most COLI programs go further, using the asset to informally finance an ongoing benefit obligation rather than only to indemnify a death.

What is the minimum size for a COLI program to make sense?

There is no statutory minimum, but the structure has fixed administrative and compliance costs. The question to ask is whether the company has a real, durable benefit obligation and capital it can commit for the long term. A company with neither is better served by simpler tools.

Who regulates COLI?

COLI is governed primarily by the Internal Revenue Code — 101(j), 264, 7702, and 409A where a deferred compensation plan is involved — along with state insurance law. Banks buying BOLI face an additional layer of federal banking supervision that does not apply to ordinary corporate buyers.

The Next Step

If you are evaluating COLI, the right starting point is a technical review of four things: the objective, the insured class, the liability design, and the compliance process. The structure has to fit the business purpose, the accounting posture, and the long-term benefit obligation — in that order.

If you already hold policies, the starting point is different: a file review to confirm that 101(j) consent exists for every insured and that the carrying assumptions still hold.

To begin, use our RISR business valuation tool for an instant baseline, or schedule a conversation to talk through whether COLI belongs on your balance sheet.

Related Resources

• COLI FAQs: Everything Business Owners Need to Know
• The Right Tool for the Right Job: BOLI for Banks, COLI for Corporations
• Institutional Corporate Owned Life Insurance (iCOLI)
• SERP + COLI: The Math Behind Cost Recovery for Executive Benefits
• Phantom Stock: Technical Deep Dive into 409A and COLI Funding
• Private Placement Life Insurance (PPLI)

External References

• 26 U.S. Code § 101 — Certain death benefits (Cornell LII)
• IRS: About Form 8925, Report of Employer-Owned Life Insurance Contracts

 

Designing COLI Around the Liability

A COLI case should be engineered around the obligation it is intended to support. That means identifying the liability, measuring the timing of the obligation, selecting appropriate insureds, and evaluating how policy performance interacts with the employer’s broader benefit design. At Schiff Executive Benefits, that planning process starts with the technical objective. We reverse engineer the structure around the company’s financial intent, the liability profile, and the compliance requirements. Whether the objective is to support deferred compensation or coordinate with Split Dollar Programs, the financing should match the promise. This methodology is central to The Perfect Plan^®.

The Technical “Insider” Advantage

When it comes to executive benefits, compliance isn’t just a checkbox, it’s the difference between a tax-free asset and a major IRS headache. This is where our expertise is unmatched. Our President, Matt Schiff, didn’t just study the laws; he helped write them. In 2003 and 2005, Matt served as a ranking member of the AALU’s NQDC Committee alongside Michael Goldstein. Together, they worked in the “room where it happened,” helping to draft the very regulations that govern IRC 409A and IRC 101(j) today. When we talk about COLI compliance, we are coming from a place of deep technical authority. We understand the nuances of IRS Form 8925 and the strict notice-and-consent requirements that must be met before a policy is issued. If you miss a single signature under IRC 101(j), your tax-free death benefit could suddenly become taxable income. Can you afford that risk? You can hear more about these technical “deep dives” and the history of these regulations by listening to Matt’s interview with Dan Hogans (formerly of the IRS Treasury) on The Perfect Plan^® Podcast. 

 

 

---

Related Resources

• The Right Tool for the Right Job: BOLI for Banks, COLI for Corporations
• Institutional Corporate Owned Life Insurance (iCOLI)
• COLI FAQs: Everything Business Owners Need to Know About Corporate Owned Life Insurance
• Phantom Stock: Technical Deep Dive into 409A and COLI Funding
• SERP + COLI: The Math Behind 100% Cost Recovery for Executive Benefits